Safety / Injuries

Shoes Set the Foundation for Proper Movement

Debunk Shoe Myths

Our experts have touched on this subject in previous posts, but if there is anything that bears repeating in fitness, it’s this:

Always, always, make sure your clients are wearing the right shoes when training.

This isn’t just for running or for serious athletes. Wearing the right shoes is important for every type of sport and every level of training and ability. The whole “one shoe fits all” mentality that many trainers run into with new clients can be severely damaging.

It is important to know that wearing the wrong shoes can cause your clients pain and injuries. The general public is often blissfully unaware of this fact and that means your client may think that the last thing he needs to think about is his shoes. Just showing up is good enough, right? Never assume your clients are shoe-smart.

There are so many ways in which people make mistakes with shoes and fitness:

  • Keeping the same shoes for several years
  • Wearing the wrong size
  • Or just wearing the wrong type of shoe

Let’s debunk some of the common untruths your clients may have about working out and shoes:

Myth: Wearing the Same Shoe for Everything is A-OK

For many new clients, this is a common misconception. They have their go-to pair of shoes sitting in their closet and they change into them to go to walk the dog, hit up the weights, play tennis, or even go on a weekend hike.

This is not a good idea. You and I both know that it’s so important to wear the proper shoes for the activity. If you are doing heavy lifting, you don’t wear your running shoes. And if you are playing a court sport, you don’t wear your walking shoes.

Different types of shoes are made for different reasons. Here are a few specific examples of how athletic shoes differ. Share these with your clients to give them an idea of what various shoes are designed to do:

  1. Running shoes are made to provide cushion and help with lateral movements. Wearing a pair of running shoes to the tennis court to play tennis will wear them out faster and will fail to provide the grip or support you need.
  2. Lifting in running shoes doesn’t keep you close enough to the ground and can cause you to get out of alignment because you don’t have the feel of the ground beneath you. Lifting shoes have a lifted and firmer heel to help generate force.
  3. Think you can play a quick pickup game at the park with your old walking shoes? Think again. Basketball shoes support multi-directional movements and even offer extra support at the ankles to prevent rolling.
  4. Even in the same category of shoes, you may need to get even more specific. For example, if you are a runner and you plan to run trails more often than any other surface you will need trail-specific shoes.

The only exception to this rule is a cross trainer. A cross trainer is made to be versatile. You can do light running and some light lifting. They also make a good all-around gym shoe, for those days when you go in and do some machines and then end up hopping on the elliptical for a few minutes.

Myth: Minimalist Shoes Are Best

Before you think I’m about to say that minimalist shoes are always bad, know this: Some people do well with minimal shoes and for some activities, minimalist shoes can be great.

But, the majority of people who try these kinds of shoes don’t do it right. They don’t follow the proper transition into wearing minimal shoes, and that can lead to injuries.

Minimalist shoes are appealing for a couple of reasons: They’re lightweight and breathable and feel almost like you aren’t wearing a shoe. But if you have gone from wearing a high cushioned and supportive running shoe for years and then suddenly jump into a minimal shoe, you can injure yourself.

Carrying extra weight can also be an issue. If your client is heavier, he needs a more supportive shoe, no matter what kinds of wonderful things he’s heard about minimal shoes.

Myth: I Can Wear the Same Gym Shoes for Years

The falsity of this statement really shouldn’t be a shocker, but for some it is. The running shoes you bought three years ago need to be replaced.

This is especially true with running shoes because cushioning is so important for protecting joints. No matter how they look or fit, if your client has been wearing the same running shoes for years, he is doing some damage. Depending on the mileage and the amount of activity done in a pair of shoes, they may not even last for half a year.

Myth: I’m Not a Serious Athlete, So I Can Buy Shoes That Look Cool

“Yes, those fluorescent yellow Nikes do look cool, but they’re not for you,” is something you may need to tell your client at some point.

The same goes for those $30 shoes found at the bargain store. Color, cool looks and price are not reasons to choose athletic shoes. It hurts to hear sometimes, but the more expensive the shoes are, the better materials and quality and the longer they will last compared to very cheap shoes.

Myth: The Tighter The Shoe The Better The Support  

Before landing on a career in personal training, I used to fit running shoes for a popular running store. We had every type of customer you could imagine, from the inexperienced first-timers to the marathoners who need a new pair of their old favorite.

It never failed to amaze me how many people, of all skill levels, were wearing the wrong size shoe and wouldn't budge when I tried to size them correctly. They would come in even after injuries and losing toenails just to get the wrong size yet again.

Wearing the wrong size shoes can cause a medley of problems. From bruised toenails to uncomfortable blisters—if you have ever had a really bad blister you know how bad this one can be.

Ideally, there should be about a thumb's width between the tip of your longest toe and the end of the shoes. This ensures that you have enough space to accommodate foot swelling.

Another good sizing tip is to pick out your shoes at the end of the day so that your feet will have expanded. When you run or stay on your feet for an extended amount of time, your feet swell and get bigger. So if your shoes are too tight, to begin with, you will run into some problems when you really get moving.

Myth: Any Shoe is Fine for RunningRunning shoes typically come in three different categories: stability, neutral, and motion control (high stability).

Running shoes typically come in three different categories: stability, neutral, and motion control (high stability). Each one is best for a different type of foot strike and gait.

  1. High stability/motion control shoes. If you have a low arch or even a flat foot and you are very flexible, you need a motion control shoe. These shoes have extra support and stability on the medial and lateral sides to help stop excessive movement while running.
  2. Stability running shoes.  Some people have flexibility and a moderate arch. These people may over-pronate a little and need more medial support to help prop up the arches and prevent you from over-pronating.
  3. Neutral shoes. If you have a high/normal arch and don’t over-pronate, then you can wear a neutral shoe. A neutral shoe has support on the outside of the shoe because a person who has high arches can tend to roll their feet outward slightly or supinate. A Neutral shoe has support for normal pronation, so if you over-pronate you will need a stability shoe.

Wearing the wrong shoe for your gait can lead to injuries, so it’s worth doing a few tests to figure out which shoes are best for you. Running store employees can help fit you, or you can try this trick at home:

Use a piece of paper or even the sidewalk. Wet your feet and step on a piece of paper or the sidewalk until you have a good outline of your foot. This will show you what kind of arches you have.

If you see a large gap between your toes and heel, you have a high arch and you should try a neutral shoe. You don't need the extra medial posting that stability shoes use.

If you see some of your foot between the heel and ball, you have medium arches and a stability shoe is best for your gait.

If your foot just looks like a flat blob, you have low arches or a flat foot and you may need more support; a motion control shoe is probably right for you.  

Myth: These Shoes Just Need to Be Broken In

Your client tells you his new shoes aren’t comfortable yet, but they look cool and were on sale and he’ll just break them in.

Wrong. You shouldn't need to break in your shoes all that much to make them feel comfortable. New athletic shoes should feel like you can wear them right out of the box.  Yes, you should wear them a few times before you commit to a longer run or walk, but if they rub or feel too tight in certain spots when you try them on, don’t count on your new shoes feeling better after putting a few miles on them.

Helping your clients avoid these common shoe mistakes can benefit them in the future. They may even avoid some of the serious injuries that sidetrack progress thanks to a simple shoe fix. And you get a happier, healthier client who continues to trust that you have the best fitness advice.

Dominique Groom

References

1. "Running Shoes: How to Choose the Best Running Shoes." REI. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Jan. 2017.

2. "What is overpronation?" Virtual Sports Injury Clinic. N.p., n.d. Web. 04 Apr. 2017.

3. "Why Olympic Weightlifting Shoes Matter." Tabata Times. N.p., 09 May 2013. Web. 10 Jan. 2017.

Related Articles

Cotton vs. Synthetic: What’s Best for Workout Gear?

Most athletic gear is pretty high-tech these days, but some people are still clinging to those old cotton sweats and t-shirts. Help your clients get material-smart when it comes to workout clothing. Here’s what you need to know...  

Considering Compression Gear

What’s the scoop on compression gear? Do you use it? Have your clients asked about it? Get the rundown on what compression gear is, how it works, and what benefits it can provide. We’ll give you all the answers so you can inform your clients and help them decide what kind of athletic gear makes the most sense for their workouts and recovery time.

Dress for Success....Or at Least Injury Prevention

If your clients aren’t wearing the right gear when you train them, they could get hurt. They could also be suffering from poor performance. You know what to wear in the gym, but your clients need your guidance. Read on to find out what to tell your clients about workout gear and how to present it to them as a way to improve performance and safety.

Comments?